Skip to content

Shipwrecks Around Martha's Vineyard Historic Map Analysis

Shipwrecks Around Martha's Vineyard Historic Map Analysis
Martha’s Vineyard · the wreck mapPhoto by MV Vacation

A vintage map of the wrecks around Martha’s Vineyard, each one marked with a little ship, a name and a year.

Analysis of a historic shipwreck map reveals dangerous waters around Martha's Vineyard. About 140 wrecks from 1746 to 1968 tell the story.

A vintage map titled Marine Disasters of Martha's Vineyard lists about 140 shipwrecks across more than two centuries, from 1746 to 1968. Below is everything it lists, area by area.

Shipwrecks by area

The map groups the wrecks by area around the island, and each entry gives the vessel's name, its type and the year it was lost.

Vineyard Haven Harbor

  • Schooner Abbie & Eva Hoover - 1911
  • Schooner Abbie G. Cole - 1910
  • Schooner Abby K. Bentley - 1898
  • Snow Africa - 1746
  • Schooner Albatross - 1857
  • Schooner Alma - 1888
  • Motor vessel Annie M. Hamilton - 1914
  • Schooner Ariadne - 1856
  • Schooner Astrea - 1857
  • Schooner A. W. Eldridge - 1858
  • Motor vessel Beatrice Earle - 1909
  • Barge Beaver - 1898
  • Schooner Bertha E. Glover - 1898
  • Barge Budget - 1898
  • Barge Byssus - 1898
  • Schooner Canaria - 1898
  • Schooner Carita - 1898
  • Schooner Cathie C. Berry - 1898
  • Schooner Charles E. Raymond - 1898
  • Schooner Christina Moore - 1898
  • Schooner Edith McIntyre - 1898
  • Schooner E. G. Willard - 1898
  • Schooner E. J. Hamilton - 1898
  • Schooner Ella F. Crowell - 1898
  • Brig Emma Cushing - 1856
  • Schooner barge Falcon - 1898
  • Schooner Gazelle - 1859
  • Schooner George H. Mills - 1898
  • Barge G. W. Patterson - 1934
  • Schooner Hector - 1898
  • Brig Helen Mar - 1855
  • Schooner James A. Brown - 1898
  • Schooner James Ponder Jr. - 1898
  • Schooner J. D. Ingraham - 1898
  • Schooner Juno - 1857
  • Bark Justice Story - 1857
  • Schooner Leora M. Thurlow - 1898
  • Schooner Lucy Hammond - 1898
  • Schooner Marion Draper - 1898
  • Schooner Martha Robinson - 1844
  • Schooner Mary Elizabeth - 1852
  • Schooner Mary E. Oliver - 1891
  • Schooner Mecklenburg - 1855
  • Schooner M. E. Eldridge - 1898
  • Schooner Nellie Doe - 1898
  • Bark Nellie M. Slade - 1898
  • Schooner Newburgh - 1898
  • Schooner Peerless - 1850
  • Schooner Quetay - 1898
  • Schooner Rebecca W. Huddell - 1898
  • Schooner Richmond - 1857
  • Brig R. H. Moulton - 1856
  • Schooner Sarah Elwell - 1859
  • Bark Tammany - 1856
  • Schooner Union - 1851
  • Brig Venus - 1855
  • Brig Vernon - 1856
  • Brig Virginia - 1856
  • Bark Warren Hallet - 1856
  • Schooner William - 1854
  • Schooner William Todd - 1898
  • Schooner Winnie Lawry - 1898
  • Schooner W. W. Dyer - 1853

Vineyard Sound, the Chops and Nantucket Sound

  • Schooner T. P. Dixon - 1895
  • Schooner Addie Sawyer - 1898
  • Fishing schooner James S. Steele - 1907
  • Yacht Flying Dutchman - 1968
  • Schooner Charles Luling - 1915
  • Schooner Sagamore - 1907
  • Fishing vessel Margie L. - 1958
  • Steamer Port Hunter - 1918
  • Schooner Julia A. Rich - 1857
  • Schooner Francis L. Taussig - 1929
  • Brig Susan - 1857
  • Fishing schooner Alice C. Jordan - 1898
  • Steamer Kershaw - 1927
  • Schooner R. L. Lewis - 1897
  • Schooner Abraham Richardson - 1900
  • Yacht Mustache - 1968
  • Schooner Island City - 1898
  • Motor vessel Water Nymph - 1938
  • Barge Florence B. - 1963

Off Martha's Vineyard

  • Brig Ellen Maria - 1850
  • Yacht Flit - 1922
  • Schooner Maud Seward - 1910
  • Motor vessel Naomi Bruce - 1929
  • Motor vessel Reliance - 1924
  • Schooner Roanoke - 1858
  • Brig Roscoe - 1852
  • Schooner Sarah Lewis - 1853
  • Schooner Waldo - 1856

Cape Poge

  • Schooner Concert - 1850
  • Cross Rip Lightship - 1864
  • Brig Empire - 1856
  • Schooner Flora - 1866
  • Schooner Silver Bell - 1856
  • Schooner Thatcher Fanton - 1852

Edgartown

  • Schooner G. W. Rawley - 1898
  • Motor vessel Mildred - 1944
  • Motor vessel Thelma - 1905
  • Schooner Willow - 1854

Off Chappaquiddick and Muskeget Channel

  • Schooner Eben Fisher - 1892
  • Schooner Christiana - 1866
  • Bark Hattie G. Dixon - 1906
  • Schooner Nellie S. Pickering - 1895
  • Fishing vessel Edith Boudreau - 1967
  • Fishing vessel Santa Cruz - 1959
  • Schooner Arthur Seitz - 1902
  • Schooner Mertie B. Crowley - 1910

The south shore and the Atlantic

  • Schooner Adelaide - 1866
  • Schooner Mary Lymburner - 1893
  • Yacht Paula's Fancy - 1966
  • Sloop Fame - 1845
  • Schooner Basile - 1913
  • Fishing vessel Portugal - 1965
  • Schooner Friendship - 1830

Off Aquinnah and Menemsha Bight

  • Fishing vessel Bonnie Bill - 1962
  • Schooner R. S. Dean - 1904
  • Schooner Amelia G. Ireland - 1898
  • Steamer City of Columbus - 1884
  • Schooner Mopang - 1906
  • Schooner Clara Leavitt - 1898
  • Steamer Herman Winter - 1944
  • Fishing vessel Connecticut - 1948
  • Schooner Nemozellie - 1907
  • Fishing vessel Wamsutta - 1964
  • Fishing vessel Constellation - 1931
  • Fishing steamer Olive May - 1910
  • Fishing vessel Agda W. - 1967
  • Fishing vessel Beret J. - 1941

Aquinnah (the map's boxed list)

  • Motor vessel Antietam - 1928
  • Motor vessel Austin L. Mills - 1924
  • Schooner Clara C. Baker - 1898
  • Sloop Eagle - 1902
  • Schooner John C. Gregory - 1905
  • Schooner John N. Roads - 1857
  • Motor vessel Little David - 1945
  • Sloop Maggie R. - 1906
  • Fishing vessel Marie & Eleanor - 1944
  • Motor vessel Old Dominion - 1908
  • Schooner Prospect - 1859
  • Schooner Queen Ester - 1898
  • Schooner Ranger - 1912
  • Schooner Vivian - 1898

What the map shows

The worst year

1898 has about 40 of the listed wrecks. Most of them went down in one storm, the Portland Gale of November 26–27, 1898, which drove a fleet of coasting schooners ashore in Vineyard Haven harbor.

Types of vessels

Schooners make up about 60 percent of the wrecks, since they did most of the coastal trading for much of this period. The rest is a mix of barks and brigs, barges, steamers, yachts and, in the 20th century, motor and fishing boats.

Seasons

Many wrecks came in the winter months, when storms were worst and visibility poorest. Rough seas, fog and poor weather forecasting made these waters dangerous to sail.

For a fall trip

The Vineyard in the Fall, free

The Derby, the beaches that open to everyone and what closes when, date by date. Free with the island letter, together with our other three island guides.

One-click unsubscribe, and we never share your email.

Notable wrecks

City of Columbus (1884)

When the SS City of Columbus struck Devil's Bridge reef, over 100 people died, one of the worst maritime disasters in Martha's Vineyard's waters. The loss led to better navigational aids and safety rules at sea.

The wider history

Large lighthouse Fresnel lens displayed inside the Martha's Vineyard Museum
M.V. Museum · the Fresnel lensPhoto by MV Vacation

The first-order Fresnel lens that once lit the Gay Head Light now fills its own two-story pavilion at the Martha's Vineyard Museum.

These wrecks span the age of sail, the move to steam and the first decades of motor fishing boats, and the number of schooners on the list shows how much coastal trade passed the island.

Many vessels were caught by sudden changes in the weather, or by navigation errors in poorly charted water.

Losses like these pushed for better-placed lighthouses and stronger rescue services, including the Life-Saving Service stations around the island.

The wrecks today

Silhouette of the East Chop Lighthouse lantern room at dusk
East Chop Light · duskPhoto by MV Vacation

The lantern room of East Chop Light at dusk.

Today many of these wreck sites draw recreational divers and marine archaeologists.

Modern navigation has made wrecks like these rare, but the same shoals and the same weather are still out there.

Reading the map

The map is a plain record of how hard these waters were on sailing ships for more than a century: about 140 wrecks, most of them working schooners, and 1898 alone accounts for about 40 of them, most in the Portland Gale of late November.

Plan the whole trip, one step at a time

Frequently Asked Questions

How many shipwrecks are on the map?

The vintage map, titled Marine Disasters of Martha's Vineyard, lists about 140 wrecks between 1746 and 1968. It boxes them for Vineyard Haven Harbor, the waters off the island, Cape Poge, Edgartown and Aquinnah, and draws the rest where they went down around the coast.

Why did so many ships sink in 1898?

Most of the roughly 40 losses listed for that year came in one storm, the Portland Gale of November 26 and 27, 1898. It drove a fleet of coasting schooners ashore in Vineyard Haven harbor. Winter storms, fog and poor forecasting made these waters hard on sailing ships for a century.

What was the worst wreck around Martha's Vineyard?

The steamer City of Columbus in 1884. It struck Devil's Bridge reef and over 100 people died. Losses like this pushed improvements in navigation aids and rescue services, including the Life-Saving Service stations around the island.

Can I dive or see any of the wrecks today?

Many of the sites draw recreational divers and marine archaeologists, but the map is a historical record, not a dive guide. If you want to get on the water, our fishing guide covers charters and the fall Derby.

Where can I see the island's maritime history in person?

The lighthouses are the easiest stop, and they were built for exactly these waters. Our island lighthouses page lists each one with visiting details, from East Chop in Oak Bluffs to Gay Head Lighthouse in Aquinnah.

Do storms like that still hit the island?

Modern navigation has made wrecks rare, but the same shoals and the same weather are still out there. For a modern example, read our account of Hurricane Bob in 1991, a hurricane that hit the island hard.

See it on video

Continue exploring Martha's Vineyard

GUIDESailing Martha's VineyardSailing in the waters around the island.→
BLOGBroad Reach Sailing AdventuresMoved to Maine in 2026; kept as a record of an island operator.→
GUIDEMartha's Vineyard travel guideThe basics before you visit.→
PHOTOSPhoto galleriesPhotos from across the island.→
LIVELive webcamsWatch Martha's Vineyard in real time.→

Four free downloads · 2026 editions

Four island guides, in your inbox

The Beach Guide (all 20 beaches decoded), The Vineyard in the Fall, the season date by date, Where to Stay, every town and price band, and What It Really Costs, the 2026 budget line by line. All four PDFs free, plus a short island letter when there is something worth telling. No schedule, no spam.

No spam, unsubscribe in one click. Want a look first? See what you get.

Disclaimer: The information in this article is provided for general guidance only and was accurate at the time of writing. Beach conditions, hours, prices, lifeguard schedules, ferry fares, and business operations change frequently and without notice. Ocean swimming carries inherent risks including rip currents, undertow, and cold water shock. Always verify current conditions with official local sources before your visit. MV Vacation assumes no responsibility for any loss, injury, or inconvenience resulting from the use of this information. Swim only where lifeguards are on duty, supervise children at all times near water, and follow all posted safety signs.

MV Vacation Blog

A guide to Martha's Vineyard, written on the island: beaches, dining, events and island living. We write down what we know about the island so your trip goes the way you hoped.

Island prices, hours and details change often. Please verify with businesses before you go. Full disclaimer

We use cookies for trip planning, site stats and ads, including ads based on your browsing. To opt out, turn on Global Privacy Control in your browser. Cookie policy

WVVY 96.7

Island radio

Still playing·