Renting a Car, Jeep or Moped on Martha's Vineyard: Agencies, Prices and the New Moped Rules (2026)

Two facts settle most of this before you start. First, bringing your own car costs a ferry reservation that sells out months ahead and a parking problem at the other end, so most visitors are better off renting on the island for the days they actually need one, or not at all. Second, the island's rental fleet is small, seasonal and priced accordingly: a Jeep in July is a splurge, a compact in October is a bargain, and a moped is now a licensed-driver, one-rider proposition in the only town that still rents them. This is the honest guide to all three: cars, Jeeps and mopeds, who rents them, roughly what they cost, and the rules that changed for 2026.

Renting a house rather than a car? The vacation rental guide is the companion to this one.

Do you need a car at all?

For a stay in a down-island town, honestly, no: the VTA bus is free through June 2027 and reaches every town and the big beaches, the bike paths link the three harbors, and the towns are walkable. Our car-free guide makes the full case. You want a car for an up-island rental house, for Aquinnah and the Chilmark beaches on your own clock, for a late dinner in Menemsha when the last bus has gone, or for a family with a week's gear. The good pattern is to arrive on foot and rent for two or three of your days rather than all of them; every agency does day rentals, and the walk-off ferry fare is a fraction of the car fare. If you are flying in, the airport guide covers the counters at the terminal.

Who rents cars on the island

A few island habits to know. Nearly every agency forbids taking the car off-island on the ferry, so the car you rent here stays here. Most will meet a boat or a flight if you tell them the time. Fleets are small, and a specific vehicle (the four-door Wrangler, the convertible) is a reservation, not a walk-up, from mid-June to Labor Day. And the beach Jeeps only earn their name with the right permit: over-sand driving needs a permit and the gear: the Town of Edgartown's for Norton Point ($90 island-registered, $140 off-island, Edgartown Parks 508-627-6145) and the Trustees' for the Chappaquiddick beaches, which our beach access and permits guide explains.

What it costs, roughly

Island rental prices move with the calendar more than the car. In peak season a compact runs from roughly $65 a day, a mid-size or small SUV in the $70s to $80s, and Jeeps from about $100 a day for a two-door and $150 for a four-door, with weekly rates that take some of the sting out; in May, September and October the same cars drop by a third or more and the agencies actually have them. Those figures are what the island agencies and rental blogs were quoting for 2026 and they change without notice, so treat them as the shape of the bill, not the bill. Add island gas, which is the most expensive in Massachusetts, and parking, which is free in most of the places that matter and impossible in the rest; the parking guide has the lots.

Mopeds: what changed

Mopeds are an island argument that has run for forty years, and in November 2025 Oak Bluffs, the only town where they are still rented, changed the rules. A special town meeting voted 68 to 6 to restrict rental mopeds to a single rider, so no passengers on the back, and to cut the number of rental licenses from five to three and the annual registration decals from 308 to 178, as the Martha's Vineyard Times reported. The bylaw went to the state for review after the vote, and the rental group has posted that it is open for the 2026 season, so assume the one-rider rule applies when you book and ask if it has been adopted.

The three moped shops are all in Oak Bluffs and all under the same ownership group: Ride-On Mopeds at 9 Oak Bluffs Avenue across from the Flying Horses, King's Rentals at 1 Circuit Avenue Extension by the fast ferries, and Island Hoppers at 23 Lake Avenue, which also rents bikes and e-bikes. Their own conditions: drivers 18 or over with a valid driver's license (licensed riders under 18 need a parent present), riders at least 4 feet 8 inches tall, and closed shoes, no sandals; they will sell you a pair for $10. Massachusetts law adds the rest: a moped is a motorized bicycle under state law, limited to 25 mph, ridden with a DOT helmet, on the road and not the bike paths or sidewalks.

Our honest view, which is also the view of the island's hospital and both newspapers: the roads that make mopeds appealing, up-island with no shoulder and sand at the edges, are the roads where the accidents happen. If you have never ridden one, the Vineyard is not the place to learn. An e-bike from the same shops gets you to the same beaches on the bike paths, and the bike routes guide shows where they go.

Mokes, e-bikes and the rest

Electric Mokes, the open beach buggies, have appeared on the island in recent seasons through the car agencies and vanished again; if you want one, ask the Oak Bluffs offices directly rather than trusting a listing, and know that they are limited to the flat down-island roads. E-bikes are rented by the moped shops and every bike rental on the island. Golf carts are not street-legal here. And if you do bring your own car, or a mainland rental with the agency's written permission, the ferry side of it is in our vehicle reservation guide.

Accessibility

None of the island agencies advertises hand-controlled vehicles, and no taxi company advertises a lift van; if you need either, bring it across on the ferry, which gives priority boarding to vehicles that must travel with a passenger with a disability. The accessibility guide covers the boats and the buses.

At a glance

How we checked this

Airport agencies are from the airport's own auto rental page; locations, fleets and moped conditions are from the companies' websites (Budget Martha's Vineyard, Martha's Vineyard Auto Rentals, the Oak Bluffs moped rental group) as of September 2026. The Oak Bluffs moped vote is from the Vineyard Gazette and the Martha's Vineyard Times, November 2025; state moped rules from the Registry of Motor Vehicles. Prices are guide figures from island agencies and rental blogs for 2026 and will move. The photographs are ours, from the rental rows in Oak Bluffs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need to rent a car on Martha’s Vineyard?

For a stay in a down-island town, honestly no: the VTA bus is free through June 2027 and reaches every town and the big beaches, the bike paths link the three harbors and the towns are walkable. You want a car for an up-island rental, for Aquinnah and the Chilmark beaches on your own clock, or for a late dinner in Menemsha after the last bus.

Who rents cars on the island?

Avis, Budget and Hertz at the airport; Budget Martha’s Vineyard, a locally owned franchise with four locations; Martha’s Vineyard Auto Rentals with offices in Oak Bluffs, Vineyard Haven and Edgartown and airport pick-up; and Sun ’n’ Fun by the Oak Bluffs harbor for Jeeps, cars and bikes.

Can I take the rental car on the ferry?

Almost never. Nearly every agency forbids taking the car off-island, so the car you rent here stays here. Most agencies will meet a boat or a flight if you tell them the time.

Should I rent for the whole trip?

The good pattern is to arrive on foot and rent for the two or three days you actually need a car. Every agency does day rentals, and the walk-on ferry fare is a fraction of the car fare. A specific vehicle, the four-door Wrangler or the convertible, is a reservation, not a walk-up, from mid-June to Labor Day.

Can I still rent a moped?

In one town only, Oak Bluffs, and under the 2026 rules it is a licensed-driver, one-rider proposition. The section on this page has the details; the bike guide covers the two-wheeled alternative.