Second Treasures MV: Inside Oak Bluffs' Antique Shop

About Second Treasures MV and John

John has loved antiques and island history all his life. Around 60% of what's in the shop comes from his own family's collection, from estate heirlooms to maritime pieces, and the rest from estate sales around the Vineyard.

John knows the island's history and its collectors, and has a habit of rescuing things, like the original Harbor View Hotel doors, that might otherwise have been lost.

A collection that keeps changing

The stock turns over often, and the shop is laid out for poking around. On a given day you might find:

• Furniture and décor: Victorian mirrors, vintage light fixtures, mid‑century pieces and architectural salvage from historic homes
• Art and photography: original works and prints by local artists, often Vineyard landscapes and maritime scenes
• Maritime collectibles: nautical instruments, scrimshaw and pieces from ships
• Porcelain and figurines: hand-painted ceramics, vintage Asian vases and decorative glass
• Everything else: cameras, textiles, old toys, oddities

Shoppers tend to mention the fair prices and the stories John tells about each piece.

Jewelry pop-ups

Now and then, mostly in summer, the shop hosts a jewelry pop-up with handmade pieces by Deborah, a local artisan. Her work is mostly silver rings, earrings and necklaces set with stones like turquoise, amethyst and opal, many of them inspired by the island.

They are a summer extra; the antiques are the main event.

What a visit is like

Most visits turn into a conversation, since John will tell you where a piece came from.

• Smaller finds are tucked into corners and onto shelves, so it pays to look around.
• John is known to work out a price on bundles and for returning buyers.
• There are paintings, antique furniture and things you didn't know you needed.

Prices

Prices run the whole range:

• Small prints, decorative objects and vintage curios: $10–$50.
• Antique chairs, framed art and décor: $50–$200.
• Salvaged doors, large maritime pieces and other big items: some over $1,000.
• Handmade rings and necklaces at the jewelry pop-ups: usually $25–$150.

Hours and location

The selection is best earlier in the day, and questions are welcome, since many pieces come with a surprising story. For furniture or shipping, it helps to get in touch ahead of time.