Best Ice Cream on Martha's Vineyard: Every Shop, Flavor and Late-Night Dessert (2026)
Mad Martha's, Ben & Bill's lobster ice cream, Back Door Donuts & 20+ more dessert spots. Flavors, prices, hours, and the only real late-night guide.
Table of contents [Show]
Oak Bluffs has a handful of waterfront restaurants worth planning an evening around. The main three are Lobsterville Bar & Grille, Nancy's, and Sand Bar — all on the water, each with a different feel.
Lobsterville Bar & Grille sits directly on the water, and from a table there you can watch the sun go down over the harbor. The kitchen does fresh seafood — a lobster roll and a drink while the light fades is a hard combination to beat. It draws locals as well as visitors, which is usually a good sign.
Nancy's Restaurant
Nancy's runs a broad menu, seafood through burgers, and handles families and bigger groups well. The upstairs bar has a good angle on the sunset.
Sand Bar is the casual one: open-air, beachside, food and drinks without any fuss. It's a good landing spot at the end of a day around Oak Bluffs.
Sunset and Ride Back to Vineyard Haven
After dinner, the ride back to Vineyard Haven is worth taking slowly — you get water views for much of the way, and it's a quiet end to the day.
More to See in Oak Bluffs
Circuit Avenue is the town's main drag, with shops, cafes, and galleries packed along a walkable stretch. The Flying Horses Carousel, the oldest operating carousel in the United States, is here too — worth a stop even without kids in tow.
Continue Exploring Martha's Vineyard
- Explore Oak Bluffs – colorful gingerbread cottages, nightlife, and family fun
- Restaurants & Dining – the best places to eat on the island
- Oak Bluffs Walking Tour
- Circuit Avenue Walking Tour
- Photo Galleries – photos from across the island
- Live Webcams – watch Martha's Vineyard in real time
📱 Island Tip of the Day — Tech
The SSA eFerry system lets you buy walk-on tickets from your phone — no standing in line. Tickets use NFC tap-to-board at the gate. Set it up before arriving.
Disclaimer: The information in this article is provided for general guidance only and was accurate at the time of writing. Beach conditions, hours, prices, lifeguard schedules, ferry fares, and business operations change frequently and without notice. Ocean swimming carries inherent risks including rip currents, undertow, and cold water shock. Always verify current conditions with official local sources before your visit. MV Vacation assumes no responsibility for any loss, injury, or inconvenience resulting from the use of this information. Swim only where lifeguards are on duty, supervise children at all times near water, and follow all posted safety signs.
